TAGS
ON CAMPUS
STUDENT LIFE
OFF CAMPUS
EDUCATION

GOVERNMENT
MONEY
COOL
VARSITY BLUES
UTSU
ADMINISTRATION
BIOLOGY
ART
MUSIC
FOOD & DRINK
ELECTIONS
IN THE LAB
FACULTY
TECHNOLOGY
HEALTH
FILM
PROFILE
NUMBERS
INTERVIEW
LITERATURE
PSYCH
BRIEFS
THEATRE
LOVE & SEX
DESIGN
GENDER
ENVIRONMENT
LONG FORM
POP CULTURE
THE VARSITY
SPACE
LAW
PRO SPORTS
SIMCOE HALL
TORONTO
HUMAN RIGHTS
MISSISSAUGA
UTSU DEFEDERATION
FROSH
SCARBOROUGH
PHOTOGRAPHY
INFOGRAPHICS
FAITH
BEST OF 2012
GUIDES
LGBTQ
FASHION
RACE
DRUGS
ALUMNI
EUREKA
EDITORIAL
DANCE
SGRT
RELIGION
JOURNALISM
INTRAMURALS
JOB MARKET
COMMUTE
INVESTIGATIVE
PODCAST
University of Toronto's Student Newspaper Since 1880

No place for anti-Canadian rhetoric on campus

disOrientation week should not sponsor offensive events

By Alanna Newman
Published: 8:51 pm, 28 September 2012
Modified: 7 pm, 30 September 2012
under
STEPHANIE TRAVASSOS/THE VARSITY
UPDATED

Last week was disOrientation week at the University of Toronto — and disorientating it was. disOrientation week aims to promote student involvement in social justice and equity projects, by hosting a series of workshops, panel discussions, and social events.

One such event, “Art Attack: Bloc Party, Mural Painting and Social Justice Fair” involved musicians, including the group Test Their Logik. Test Their Logik had a thing or two to say about Canada, specifically, “Fuck the maple leaf, I’ll never fly that fucking flag again.”

There is no room on a Canadian university campus for anti-Canadian rhetoric, and it is not the place of a students’ union, representing student voices, to endorse groups that spread hateful, anti-Canadian messages.

The UTSU is known for holding controversial views, and promoting controversial policies, such as their support for the student protests in Quebec. The event’s other sponsor, the Ontario Public Interest Research Group (OPIRG), is infamous for their open support of various contentious campaigns, including Israeli Apartheid Week.

The UTSU is elected to represent students, and prides itself on creating “open, inclusive spaces.” But there was nothing open, nor inclusive, about this recent event. This is indeed a new low on campus: anti-Canadian sentiments blasted in front of Hart House, at an event hosted by the students’ union.  OPIRG claimed that the “art attack is a creative boost in an otherwise average day.” They could have more aptly called it an attack on Canada, and a rude shock on an otherwise average day.

The students’ union has no place hosting an event that aims to divide students along pro- and anti-Canadian lines. Being Canadian is something to be incredibly proud of.

UTSU vice president-external Abigail Cudjoe said of disOrientation week, “The intention of the week is to inform students of social justice and equity and to encourage students to get more involved and to know about what we do, and what it means to be part of social justice.” OPIRG’s website advertises disOrientation week as an event that “fosters student activism, educates and agitates social change and works to connect campuses and student issues.” Student involvement on campus is a wonderful sentiment to promote, but I question what is achieved through mediums that resort to repeating “Fuck the maple leaf.”

When questioned about the role that the UTSU played in this horrifying show, Cudjoe explained that she was “surprised that those lyrics were in the song and didn’t know that they would be.” While that may be true, it is the UTSU’s responsibility to do their due-diligence before hosting an event. A simple online search will reveal that Test Their Logik has drawn criticism along these lines before, and reveal their offensive song lyrics. Is it too much to ask that elected, paid student representatives perform a background check on any guests they invite to campus, and take responsibility for what they present to the student body?

The only thing that hurt more than the performance by Test Their Logik was that students applauded. This is not something that we, as students, should encourage. I am proud to be Canadian. But it is clear that there is a disconnect between the UTSU, OPIRG, and the student body.

The UTSU funds many worthwhile clubs at the University of Toronto, and provides some meaningful services to students. They also fight to make U of T an inclusive space. Perhaps this event slipped through the cracks. Regardless, it was unacceptable, disappointing, and alarming. The UTSU must work to make U of T an inclusive space for all students — including those who are proud to be Canadian. They must make sure that any group they co-host an event with on campus is promoting inclusive content.

It is not too late for the UTSU to denounce these sentiments, nor is it too late for OPIRG to publically apologize for this event. It is okay to be Canadian and to say “I’m sorry”— after all, that’s something we are known for.

I hope that UTSU and OPIRG will remember to conside whom and what they host on campus. I look forward to their response to this article, and hope that together we can make the University of Toronto a place where being Canadian is something to be celebrated.

 

 

  • Damian

    You have every right to say that the sentiment “Fuck the Maple Leaf” hurt your feelings. But going farther, and saying that such sentiments have no place on campus, is to ignore what campuses are for, which is exposure to different varieties of thought and expression.

  • Hardy Weinberg

    All rhetoric is welcome on campus, and it is up to students to discern through it to find relevant facts. YES the like “Fuck the Maple Leaf” is rhetoric (and offensive to me), probably it is a critique on canadian government or discriminitory social policies in our country. But, this article arguing that one line from one band that played at disorientation somehow makes UTSU and OPIRG inherently anti-canadian is the classic neo-McCarthy rhetoric I would expect from conservatives like Alanna Newman.

    Should Newman’s rhetoric that people can be divided into “anti-canadian” and “pro-canadian” based on certain views that were expressed by an indie band be silenced? No! Then why silence a band uses the rhetoric of “Fuck the Maple Leaf” to criticize the government or social policies?

    The real reason for this article is that Alanna Newman doesnt like the UTSU, OPIRG and generally more liberal politics (often under the banner of “Social Justice”). By using this incident to paint them all as “anti-canadian” Alanna Newman uses the same type of rhetoric she decries.

  • CanadaIsAColonialWarMachine

    Fuck you.

  • lol

    lol are you fucking serious? A university campus is the site of free-thinking academc enterprise and therefore in every way a ground for free political/social expression. That’s what makes it different then other public spaces, even those like Queen’s Park and the City Hall square. Sure, I don’t agree with the pro-abortion nutcases that rally around Robarts every week, but they have every right to be there, and so does disOrientation. Wow, can’t believe an university newspaper contributor like you don’t even understand what a university is all about.

  • Truth Bomb

    People have every right to dissent against nationalism on campus and be given a space to do so outside of the classroom, which often fosters an environment that caters toward Eurocentric and colonial attitudes. Not everyone is proud to be “Canadian” or feels included in the prodominantly pro-nationalistic spaces on campuses. OPRIG and UTSU are working to provide space for marginalized groups. Ask a First Nations person or Quebecois how they feel about being “Canadian”, where is their space on campus? All I can say to this article is: crocodile tears. Until you experience or even seek to understand the history of colonialism and its continuation to this day in Canada I am sure you will keep unquestioningly flying that maple leaf forever.

    • THISbot

      THIS!

  • MapleLeafForever

    If you do not like Canada or what it represents then get back on the plane and go back to where you came from. No, didn’t think so. Yes bands and people have the right to say what they want, why? Because Canadian law allows it. Try saying fuck the ayatollah in Iran and see what you get. Why do we have these laws? Because Canadians have fought and died to protect them. You fools that defame Canada flying the flag of intellectual freedom are just that, fools. The UTSU is supposed to represent all student members. However they seem to only cater to left wing fanatics who know not what they speak of. By the way loudspeakers only increase your volume not the value of your content. Where is the opt out option? UTSU does not speak for me.

    • Dora The Explorer

      “If you do not like Canada or what it represents then get back on the plane and go back to where you came from. ”

      First off, you’re assuming everybody who dissenting here is an immigrant . And then, you resort to the idea of “if you don’t agree with me, gtfo.” Way to go.

      “The UTSU is supposed to represent all student members”

      True, but this does not translate to do no advocacy at all. It’s a union, advocacy is part of its job. Part of that is equity and representing students who are part of groups who are oppressed, disORIENTATION week (which btw: happens in Feb. at McGill, where their student union partners up with QPIRG) is designed to educate students on the issues these marginalized groups face. Yes, this person said something radical (which when used outside the context of violence, just means that, what you are saying is challenging the status-quo, not necessarily a bad thing) but historically, university campuses are the home of radical speech.

      Then you say the UTSU is supposed to represent all student members. Fair, but I’m tired of proponents of this, constantly arguing that by not espousing their radical right wing pov (not realizing how much of a miniority they are on campus), the UTSU is not representing students. They would like a UTSU that does no advocacy, even when it comes to educational issues.

      • MapleLeafForever

        If you agree with the lyrics of this band and you are Canadian then you are traitorous, perhaps you should consider getting on the plane as well. If you think immigrants are oppressed in this country you are disillusioned. Immigrate to another country, perhaps one where your downtrodden friends come from, see how you are treated and compare. Honestly, this band takes advantage of every opportunity this country gives to them (most likely including grants) and throws it in the face of every tax paying citizen. You are correct, the social structure on campus is reversed. So while you on the radical left lord over the entire spectrum of campus life, including a lot of the curriculum, we “radicals” will quietly complete our studies and promptly start our careers in the real world. Have fun with your equity degree that promotes hatred of certain groups, in this case Canadians.

        • Hardy Weinberg

          Ah, yes, as usual we have gone from neo-McCarthy patriotism tests to outright xenophobia. You ask me to talk to my “downtrodden” friends and ask me to immigrate to their country. First, most of my friends who did immigrate at some point in time are now Canadians, with all the rights it entails. Viewing them as any less makes them second class citizens in our country.
          Those who are not (majority of whom are international students) are contributing members of society and should not be viewed any less than anyone else, especially they should not be called “downtrodden”. Now for a bit of rhetoric, if being Canadian (a nation built by immigrants) means to call immigrants “downtrodden” and telling people to go back to their country or another country, then there is something fucked up about being Canadian.

          Also, I am sick of this “our forefathers fought for our rights” rhetoric. Many of the people who fought for the rights we enjoy are First Nations people, whose rights we have promptly taken away. Furthermore, many of my friends of South Asian, African and Middle Eastern backgrounds had grandparents or great grandparents who fought for the Allies in WW2. some of whom are immigrants themselves or children of immigrants. If ancestral struggle for freedom is a requirement to be entitled to those freedoms then many immigrants, minorities and First Nations people should be the first people recieving those rights.

    • speakthetruth

      I would suggest that you get on the plane. you live on land that has been stolen through government enforced genocide, the very thing that is being discussed in this song. If you are proud of that, then you might want to consider the benefit to humanity of genocide? Why does one need to defend all of Canada’s actions, including genocide? can germans not critique the holocaust? can israelis not question the occupation of palestine? can the chinese not question countless inhuman practices of their dictatorship? Are we just supposed to say “i love my country therefore I condone everything that it does all the time”?

      true love comes from seeing the truth of something. i happen to love Canada, the land base and what the government was doing to have a more peaceful, humane country (pre-harper). However, in that love I can look long and hard at the atrocities committed in colonialisms name and say “no, those are not right and there is no way that we should be perpetuating that system that continues to this day through reservations and total lack of honouring treaties etc of the indigenous peoples.” because i love this country and want to see it as something other than a means to oppress and divide. I want it to be something that brings us together.

      so yes, i totally understand anti-canadian sentiment. there are many things happening in Canada currently that make me ashamed to be Canadian, done in my name. To call those things out, to speak their truths in an institution of higher learning, where new and radical thoughts are, historically, supposed to be examined, well, i think that’s perfectly academic.

    • seriously

      Yeh, only the British National Party speaks for you…xenophobic hate monger.

    • shutup

      Oh I am sorry, did we hit you right in the white-priviledge? Get over it.

  • TurtleIsland

    I know that song… it is called “Turtle Island”, after what many Native peoples called North America. It is about protecting the environment, the shock and anger felt towards Canada upon learning about its genocidal residential schools. It’s one of my favorite songs of all time. Let’s put the anti-maple leaf sentiment into context here:

    “Protect mother earth don’t settle for less, this is turtle island don’t you ever forget, we got one planet let’s protect what’s left, this is turtle island don’t you ever forget!” X2
    “This aint’ Canada, this is turtle island man, fuck the maple leaf I’ll never fly that fuckin flag again.” is one lyric. the verse goes on to say: “shouldn’t we be ashamed that they kidnapped kids and kept them encaged,
    taught them propaganda, poisoned their brains,so that their own culture made them ashamedand dumped tens of thousands in unmarked gravesCanadian Genocide, Church and StateCanadian Genocide, never again”

    I just watched a film about the residential schools the other day. An estimated 42% of the kids held in them died. And this isn’t ancient history, as the truth and reconciliation commission is doing their inquiry now, about 20 years after the last school was closed. This is exactly what we should be learning on campus.

    • THISbot

      THIS!

  • Evan

    This is a brilliant satire piece. Cheers.

  • Anonymous

    Let’s tackle the real issue at hand which is whether or not “disorientating” is a real word.

  • LtClout

    It’s free speech, debate, art, and criticism — all of which belong, surely more than anywhere else, on a university campus. Open your mind and ask questions instead of dumping scorn; you might learn something.

  • Anonymous

    I kept checking to see if this article was a parody but it wasn’t. What a right-wing piece of crap. What you’re basically saying is that some art is ‘wrong’ and then you pull out the Nixonian ‘my country right or wrong’ theme as a defence. What a total nerd. Get a life you sad thing. Get a life.

  • Jamis of Doon

    ‘”I’m sorry,” just ain’t good enough.’

    The appologised-for oppressive actions and attitudes are STILL present amongst Canada’s citizens, administrations AND corporations.

    Stop appologising and start breaking the cycle.

  • Ty

    If this writer is seeking a career with the Postmedia or the Sun News Network, she definitely has that style down. A campus newspaper is supposed to suport strong progressive views, not be a mouthpiece for over sensitive nationalists.

    • BK

      If you’re saying that a campus newspaper must support left-wing views, you’re just as bad as someone who says that an artist should be silenced on the basis of political views.

  • loveandpeace

    Oh for goodness sake I was so confused. At first I was thinking the writer was a most brilliant satirist, but upon re-reading I am thinking she might be serious. Yikes. Oh horrors, ‘the students applauded…’ that line broke me up. That was like that old nun on Saturday Night Live.

  • Karen Krisfalusi

    F%#k this writing. It sucks.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=534046216 Curtis OfThe Human-Family

    And trying to say you can’t have expressions of free speech and expression is abhorrent in a so called free and democratic society. Thanks, for that. asshole. Oh, ya, fuck the maple leaf. the only way I’ll fly that flag ever again is if it’s burning.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=534046216 Curtis OfThe Human-Family

    And I’m SOOO proud of being a settler….ya, sooo effin proud to be from a country that practices apartheid so well, that nearly everyone forgot about it. Or forgot to care. I’ve never forgetten to care. I’m proud of that. fuck CANADUH. This is Turtle Island, Don’t you ever forget.